Okuma Metaloid 5Ns Tutorial + Angular Contact Bearing mod

Started by boon, June 07, 2016, 10:37:42 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

boon

Start by backing off the preload knob until it comes off the reel - the handle has to be on the right angle before this will pop off. Don't try to pull the lever off yet, the spool shaft makes it tricky at this stage.


The knob is ratcheting... it uses 2 tiny little pins in the knob that have even tinier springs underneath. Don't lose these wee blighters, they will make a getaway given half a chance. They work against the little detents in the drag cam.



Grab a T10 screwdriver and remove the 3 stainless steel sideplate screws. These are greased from the factory, nice touch, I hate to see Loctite on these screws as they can be hard enough to remove anyway.
Pop the side plate off.... the drag lever and cam will probably drop off at this point.


The sideplate has some cool stuff going on. Most obvious is all the stainless steel in here. It all has a light coat of grease from the factory, again good to see. This reel (and I believe the Andros as well?) uses a double dog system with silent "dog-ears" gripping the anti-reverse ratchet. The dogs are alternating on the 16 tooth ratchet, meaning you'll never get more than 11.25 degrees of back-play in the reel. If you look at how the dogs engage with the gear you'll see that you're never going to make this anti-reverse system slip unless you either smash the dog to pieces or it sheers off the post in the side-plate.


The drag plate has a bearing in it, 6x13x3.5 - shielded and greased.


The drag washer is a large carbon fibre item, according to the box it's greased with Cal's Drag Grease and it definitely has something on it.


After removing the 2 stainless steel screws holding down the dogs you can lift out the entire ratchet gear and dogs as a unit. Don't try to get the gear out with the dogs in place or you risk damaging the ears that grip it. If you can keep the dogs exactly in the position they were when you remove them it makes reassembly much easier.
At this point you can pluck out the pinion gear with the little drive adaptor on it.


Next you remove the plastic gearbox shield at the bottom, then you shout at the big E-clip on the driveshaft for about 5 minutes until it pops off. Don't let it go flying!! Then you can lift out the drive gear, cross-pin and the 4 washers - 1 on top, 3 underneath.
At this point you can slide the driveshaft and handle out of the reel. Note there is a washer on the outside too, it may remain stuck to the outside of the side-plate.
Check out that drive gear! Burly as, along with the oversized driveshaft it runs on.
The shaft runs on a large brass bushing - I would guess oil impregnated - and it runs quite smoothly on this too. The Andros has bearings here which make the reel slightly smoother but I was surprised at how easily the driveshaft spun in it. This bushing seems to be pressed in and I don't think there's any real way you could change it to a bearing or instant anti-reverse bearing.


At last you can pop out the pinion bearing - its 6x17x6, a common size in lever drag reels around this size. This one is shielded and well packed with grease. As you'll know if you've fished lever drags much the pinion bearing is the limiting factor in terms of drag - as the drag increases the whole assembly squashes this bearing, apply too much preload and the reel will get grindy and eventually the bearing will collapse.
Now for the sake of "can it be done" and the kiwi spirit of always thinking we can improve things I'm replacing this bearing with an angular contact bearing. These are made to take axial loads where a normal bearing doesn't like them at all. Note that this probably voids the hell out of your warranty... oh well.
The bearing I'm using is a 706C from VXB.com


These come un-greased, unshielded and it's a chrome steel bearing so I packed it with a saltwater-rated lithium bearing grease - this is a horrible messy job..........
I popped this in the sideplate then reversed the process to reassemble it.


I also pulled the spool out, and because I forgot to tape the spool before removing it the heavy fluorocarbon leader went a bit mental, there was much cursing. The spool and frame looks to be machined aluminium (from billet?), continuing the theme in this reel.



The spool and shaft assembly is a bit of a bugger to get apart, there is another e-clip that is under tension from the belleville washers inside the spool and it requires quite a lot of shouting to make it all go back together so I'm not going to go into that today :) The spool bearings are shielded. I got 22 seconds of spin-time from the spool-on-shaft assembly, pretty good.
Note there is this fiddly little cross-pin at the end of the spool shaft, if you don't line it up just right with the slot in the frame your (nicely taped) spool won't drop back in.


Once it was all back together I did some drag testing.

Before changing the bearing I could get about 8.5kg of drag out of the reel with the lever rammed up to Full but at this point the handle was getting really raspy. This translated to all of maybe 3kg at Strike. Not bad, but not exactly amazing either.

With the angular contact bearing in there it was a different story. I could wind in around 12.5kg of drag on this little tank, at Full. The handle does get harder to turn but it's still smooth, not grindy or binding. Still had perfect freespool and gave line smoothly. I reckon I could have dialed some more in but the lever was getting hard to push up to full and I was starting to worry about the threads on the end of the spool shaft! This translates to about 8kg of drag at strike which is heaps for the 50lb braid it's spooled with. Realistically I will probably dial it back to around 9kg at Full as I felt like I was probably stressing other parts of the reel at over 12kg.
Pretty impressive from such a little reel!

I've got it spooled with right on 200m of Daiwa J-Braid 50lb, which is pretty thick for 50lb and I reckon breaks well over rated strain. Line lay is really nice, it's basically self-managing with how narrow it is.

strathy

Hi Boon,
Thankyou for a brilliant piece of work you,ve done for us all.
You,ve shown everything I really wanted to know about the Metaloids, though I will have to transpose some of your instructions, as mine are LHW, and 2 speed.
Good to see that they are properly greased from the factory, saves me having to crack them open before my first trip in 2 weeks time. but when I do I,ll try to get photos of the diferences to add to this thread, or start another.
Interesting what you say about Daiwa J braid, Its what I,m going to put on my 5IILX, Euro spec is 0.35mm/78lb whereas NZ spec I,ve seen is 0.36mm/50lb ????
I,m going to put the 5 on an JM ODul and the 12 on the JM ODml.
Mike

boon

I believe the NZ stuff is marketted as knot-strength where the euro spec is marketted as absolute breaking strain? Or at least something along those lines. Good to know it's probably at least 80lb although it makes me think I should drop down to something thinner and get more on the reel.

I know I've got stuck twice with this stuff and breaking it is incredibly hard work, if it's actually 50lb breaking strain I'll be amazed. I've just spooled an Okuma SLX-50WII with the 80lb and I bet it's over 100lb ABS.

mike1010

Nice write-up.   Thanks.  It will be interesting to see how that new bearing holds up over time.

Mike

maxpowers

Does anyone know if there are stronger version of the e-clip at the end of the spool shaft next to the cross pin?  Every time I dialed up the drag on my metaloids to anything higher than 18+ lbs at strike, the clip will deform and pop out of the slot.

Arthur1

Would this bearing modification be identical in size to the 2 speed version of the 5 models?

Gfish

Great tutorial, Boon. Your attention to interesting detail makes it an: "across the experience spectrum" - good read( for example, the pre-load knob stuff). Probably alota work, but if do onea these, that's how I'd like ta do it.
Any idea how much in US currency that angular contact bearing cost?
Gfish
Fishing tackle is an art form and all fish caught on the right tackle are"Gfish"!

boon

Quote from: Arthur1 on October 10, 2017, 05:50:15 PM
Would this bearing modification be identical in size to the 2 speed version of the 5 models?

Unsure, I've never had a 2-speed apart. If I were to do this again, I would install a spool shaft as well, to support the inner race of the left side spool bearing - once you've got an AC bearing in there the left spool bearing is next in the firing line.

Quote from: Gfish on October 10, 2017, 06:14:58 PM
Great tutorial, Boon. Your attention to interesting detail makes it an "across the experience spectrum", good read( for example, the pre-load knob stuff). Probably alota work, but if do onea these, that's how I'd like ta do it.
Any idea how much in US currency that angular contact bearing cost?
Gfish

Thanks :) $13 from here: http://www.vxb.com/706C-Angular-Contact-Bearing-6x17x6-Miniature-p/kit14248.htm
As mentioned, they are chrome steel, I got about 9 months of regular fishing in saltwater out of mine before corrosion became an issue.

Tiddlerbasher

When performing a similar mod on an original Andros 5 I used 2 AC bearings - left side spool and pinion bearing (they are both axially loaded when drag is applied).
I also fitted a sleeve on the spool shaft and removed the c-clip on the left side spool shaft. This made it much easier to fit the retaining pin after the bellevilles. Simply back off the preset drag as much as possible fit the bellevilles and washer then fit the pin - easy as you don't have to compress the bellevilles - which on the Andros was a royal pita.
Although similar in many ways the Metaloid and Andros use different sized spool and pinion bearings. The Andros used 6x15x5mm bearings. I purchased my ac bearings from GMN.
Judging by the price they were made of Unobtanium. I never did find any stainless ac bearings - although a couple of Chinese companies did offer to produce some for me - like I need 500 bearings Doh!
Although they did the job - ie reduced the cranking resistance - backing of the strike drag to 10lbs (20lbs full) produced a similar result at zero cost ;) In reality I very much doubt that I ever use more than 10-15lb drag with 50-60lb braid.