I personally like the darker stuff better, and Jonathan has found the last pound of grease in Alan's garage...and now only his reels has that grease.

All the hype of this grease is based on what we have used over the years. We are sure there are a lot of other grease and grease mixtures out there that are good enough and better. As long as it suit your needs and if you do regular maintenance, you should not have any issues.
Bryan