Reel Repair by Alan Tani

Spinning Reel Rebuild Tutorials and Questions => D.A.M. Quick => Topic started by: PacRat on April 09, 2022, 12:10:32 AM

Title: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: PacRat on April 09, 2022, 12:10:32 AM
I bought this 110N one fleabay. The exterior looked really clean so I pulled the trigger. It came in today and as soon as I turned the crank I knew it was more than just dried up vintage grease. Now I need to start another parts list for Fred. Does anyone have a photo of where this spring goes or if it even belongs in there?

(https://alantani.com/gallery/36/14769-080422235403-36690137.jpeg)

(https://alantani.com/gallery/36/14769-080422235413-366912302.jpeg)

-Mike
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: oldmanjoe on April 09, 2022, 12:19:38 AM
You got it rite the first time , it does not belong there .
 That spring part number is not in this reel no how no way,in the way of the spool.......
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: Wompus Cat on April 09, 2022, 01:01:07 AM
That spring looks like the Spring that goes on the Condensor of a  1959 2.5 Horse Power Briggs and Stratton Lawnmower Engine I lost back in the Day . It has been Modified a Wee Bit but sure looks like it would fit with turnin another coil on it .
 
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: foakes on April 09, 2022, 01:09:39 AM
Oh!

That is where I lost the spring for the accelerator return on my Honda 6.5!

Just make a grocery list of what you need, Mike —-

I will send it out.

Best, Fred
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: oldmanjoe on April 09, 2022, 01:21:18 AM
 :D  Do you need a picture of the hula hoop spring and part number ?
 
     #  103-340
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: PacRat on April 09, 2022, 02:32:00 AM
Thanks Joe, I completely missed the hula hoop spring when I looked at the schematic. I guess I was fixated on that goofy coil spring. It had the rotor nut and washer over the top of it so it just looked like the coil spring was just sort of skewed out of place. I started tugging on it and could tell it wasn't budging. There's no hula hoop spring rattling around in there either.
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: oldmanjoe on April 09, 2022, 03:05:35 AM
Hula hoop spring    AKA  switch pin spring   Just in case some one is looking for it  !!
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: PacRat on April 09, 2022, 03:32:44 AM
Now that makes sense! After you showed me the schematic, I ran out to the bench and made one. I was fairly close (for just seeing the schematic) but the spring stock was too heavy. It fit but a little too much force.
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: oldmanjoe on April 09, 2022, 03:45:12 AM
IT is a lite spring wire About .018 wire .
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: foakes on April 09, 2022, 04:47:09 AM
Got plenty...

Best, Fred
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: jgp12000 on April 09, 2022, 12:00:57 PM
Did this Googan also state the 110N was ready to fish?
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: Gfish on April 09, 2022, 02:05:28 PM
Should be interesting to see what's in the gearbox. Then again, the way these are built, "the googan" may never have had to open it.
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: PacRat on April 09, 2022, 03:01:43 PM
The gearbox is pretty clean. Looks like some of the original grease has been evacuated and the bearing feels a bit dry. Seems like they mostly just monkey with the winding cup and bail judging by the rash on the bail screws.

I looked back at the listing and the seller said they hadn't 'fished it'...I wonder if that means they hadn't 'fixed it' also?? I've learned from Tommy and Fred about steering clear of beaters and this one looked like a low mileage gem in the photos. At first I thought it was just a little stiff with old grease but then I felt the grind  and the bail had no snap to it. It would only close half way.

The guy hadn't listed any other fishing gear so I'm assuming he picked it up at a garage sale or something. It's interesting just how critical that hula-hoop spring is and it's difficult to asses the rest of the reel without the bail trip functioning properly. The gearbox feels pretty good without the winding cup attached...maybe only a bearing required there?
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: Midway Tommy on April 09, 2022, 04:00:23 PM
At least the exterior looks like it wasn't abused too bad. You've won half the battle right there. Fred can easily rescue you on any needed or missing parts, they're not very complicated and bearings are an easy fix.

I'm thinking your yard/garage sale scenario may be on the money. It probably didn't work and some novice that had no idea the wire spring was missing Rube Goldberged something to suffice just to get rid of it.

You'll no doubt get it top notch, Mike. ;)
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: Gfish on April 09, 2022, 04:14:23 PM
Just me, but if there's no significant noise or rotor wobble, I'd prolly just grease the ball bearing and see if it's acceptable, as it's not as critical as a spool bearing on a baitcaster.
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: PacRat on April 09, 2022, 06:40:29 PM
Before I sink any money into a reel I like to make certain it a viable candidate. With this 110N I have isolated different components to make certain there's no un-seen damage that would relegate it to the bone-yard. I put the winding cup back on with all the bail-trip mechanism removed and it feel pretty darned good for not being cleaned yet. Here's a photo of the gear box.

(https://alantani.com/gallery/36/14769-090422182952-366921576.jpeg)

(https://alantani.com/gallery/36/14769-090422183001-366931967.jpeg)

Thank you Joe and Fred for the photos and specs for the hula-hoop. Here's the crude one I made from the schematic yesterday. My wire was double the diameter it should have been and the geometry was off on the triangle. This first attempt was way to heavy to function. The bail wire is off a little too and will require some minor tweaking. At least now I know the housing is all straight and that all the other parts are there.
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: PacRat on April 09, 2022, 08:18:57 PM
Well I bent a better hula-hoop with 0.022 music wire, The geometry and fit seemed spot on but not enough memory in the wire. It wasn't stainless anyway. I tweaked the bail and the bail spring. The bail is nice and snappy now. I reassembled the real sans the hula-hoop and she runs smother than a lot of my other reels (without doing any cleaning yet). I took the spool apart to be certain I didn't need any other parts and the entire drag stack was missing. I'm glad I checked before placing an order.
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: foakes on April 09, 2022, 09:15:17 PM
That is a good job on that switch spring, Mike —-

However the pressure tolerances are critical on these springs —- basically, they need enough spring to last another 40 years.

You and I may not have the reel that long —- but if approached from the idea that someone else will have it after you and I —- your good work will be silently appreciated, if not actually known.  And that is enough.

Working on reels today —- went out to the outer shop to get a few parts —- and ran across these.

Interestingly enough —- this is a very clever and durable system for tripping the bail —- plus the 3-position setting adjustment for the bail trip pressure is unique.

I think out of maybe 1000 "N's" I have worked on —- I might have only replaced this spring a half dozen times.

Best,

Fred

Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: PacRat on May 21, 2022, 08:10:43 PM
I've been away for work and while I was out I received a package from Fred with the trip spring and some drag washers for the 110N (not to mention a whole lot of other goodies).

The new trip spring is in and it works flawlessly 99% of the time. I'm thinking the little plastic bumper on the slide needs replacing (maybe it has shrunk over the years?).

Now I'm noticing that I'm still shy on some drag components. I also purchased another 110N so I'll post photos of both for comparison. I think neither one was 100% correct.

(https://alantani.com/gallery/36/14769-210522185016-367951703.jpeg)
Here are both with the original on top (with the washers from Fred) and the new one at the bottom is exactly as received.

(https://alantani.com/gallery/36/14769-210522184950-367941676.jpeg)
Here's the schematic. I have a little confusion if the 110N requires only 3 washers in front or if you just substitute those 3 for the ones required for the rest of the series.

(https://alantani.com/gallery/36/14769-210522185029-367961746.jpeg)
Here's the way I stacked it in my best interpretation of the schematic. Please let me know if I need to remove or swap any of them. Once I get it sorted out correctly, I'll order up enough washers to complete the other spool.

Have any of you substituted carbons for the asbestos? The asbestos are very thick and I believe I would need additional shim washers. Also, are the asbestos washers glued to the spool? Mine came out easy enough but they seem to have glue residue on the back side.

-Mike
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: foakes on May 21, 2022, 09:29:45 PM
Here is the proper setup, Mike —-

As the schematic shows —- the 110N is different from the other (6) in the "N" series.

Brake spindle
Ratchet wheel
(2) brass round washers
Bridge plate
Under spool asbestos washer
Spool
Over spool asbestos washer
Keyed metal washer
Spring ring washer
Brake nut

As for CF's —-

This is a lightweight Microlight reel that will generally fish 4 to 6 pound test.

The hexagon asbestos washers are very tough and long-lasting.

With one on top and one under the spool —- you end up with a "squeeze" drag affair that is very effective and balanced to adjust the spool drag tension.

With the other components in place that are all working together —- there is really no need for CF's, IMO.

It just complicates an already solidly engineered system —- and other measure will need to be adjusted for smoothness and line lay. 

Try it properly set to stock —- and I think you will see the benefit.

Do not grease the asbestos washers —- use them dry.

If anything else is needed —- just let me know.

Best, Fred
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: PacRat on May 21, 2022, 10:05:05 PM
Perfect! Thank you Fred.
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: foakes on May 21, 2022, 10:10:54 PM
Oh Yeah, also Mike —-

You do not need to glue in the under spool hex asbestos washer.

It will stay in place with no issues.

Best, Fred
Title: Re: I bought Googan's 110N
Post by: PacRat on May 22, 2022, 12:35:33 AM
Thanks Fred. The first one (Googan's with the goofy spring) is fully functional now. I also replaced the little band on the trip slide with a short piece of aquarium tube. The bail is now functioning at 100%. When I get some time I'll give both of these 110Ns a complete flush 'n' lube. These are great little reels. I wish I had them when I had more time for fishing. Looking forward to using them.