I have to ask... I've been watching a reel on ebay for 7 days now and it just went off for $1625. I bid $1000
But clearly wasn't even close :-\. Just curious if one of my compadres was the lucky winner? This is a museum quality piece with the box in unreal condition (80 years old!). Here's the link so use can all drool like I've been for 7 days.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/VINTAGE-PENN-SENATOR-GAME-FISHING-REEL-No115-9-0-STAINLESS-STEEL-w-ORIG-BOX-/191221468798?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&autorefresh=true&hash=item2c85b00e7e&nma=true&si=WR7pxCBq711c3P2g1it%252BkGbOq14%253D&orig_cvip=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.l2557
Keep those eyes open for hidden treasures like this one ...and then call me so we can make a deal. ;)
Dom
Must've gone to a big-time collector... no one in their right mind would actually fish with such a museum-quality piece.
For that much dough, I'd buy several Internationals and have 'em souped up by Cal. :D
~A~
I saw that. A first edition. Sorry you didn't get it Dom. It wasn't me brother. I have as many 9/0's as I do 12's. ;)
Really unique, and amazing condition. Sorry you missed it.
Very nice reel. I wonder if it came with the leather thumb drag. Too bad you didn't get it Dom.
Dom
If it was a Newell I would have bid on it.
Mike
Not I, way out of my budget.
I missed seeing that one, must've been mighty purty.
Sorry to hear your bid got trumped so hard.
Quote from: bluefish69 on June 28, 2014, 03:28:31 AM
Dom
If it was a Newell I would have bid on it.
Mike
Carl Newell was a child when that reel was made.
Doc
I sounded good ---- I think
Mike
Quote from: bluefish69 on June 28, 2014, 05:06:40 PM
Doc
I sounded good ---- I think
Mike
I let you slide on that one Mike, I have too many Newell friends ;D
BTW, it wasn't me guys, I wouldn't have paid more than $200 for that reel. :-\
i'd like to see the collection of the man that bought that one!
I missed that eBay listing. Dom, thanks for posting. I am with Alan, I would like to see his other reels.
John
I knew I would get a beating from someone but had to do it anyway.
Mike
Thanks crew, was really hoping to see te collection of the collector that bought it (like Alan said). :o
Sal, I believe, agree, and pretty much follow everything you do, but if you'd only bid $200 on that reel... You just didn't want it in the first place. That's a piece of fishing reel history right there. Can't help but think the IGFA may have bought that for the fishing hall of fame. It certainly would be a piece they would acquire.
Anyway, keep your eyes peeled.
Thanks
Dom
I believe that was someone's missing piece, usually you don' t get a chance to bit on any of those with the wooden handle with no line that haven't been used.
Someone always makes an offer that a seller can't refuse, eBay rules or not, they always disappear.
That reel wouldn't have had much value for me or you, unless you had most the others with the same feature, still would have been nice to have.
Few years back I bit on a new 12/0, same as what you see above, that one was new. I thought if I placed a bit the seller would let the auction run...wrong, it disappeared :-\.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/L-K-VINTAGE-PENN-SENATOR-No115-9-0-STAINLESS-STEEL-1936-37-/281372302164?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item4183189b54
I think this might have been the fellow. He is selling this one since he has a new one. Just a Guess.
I don't remember ever seeing a knob as the one Dom showed us on the larger Senators above :-\. The one you're showing I've seen before, that one must have been a year after, but I'm not sure. The information that I have only goes back to 1938, these are from that era:
(http://i766.photobucket.com/albums/xx305/pescatore3/86fb835b-38ea-4685-947f-cfa2adeef9ea_zps7117f3ce.jpg) (http://s766.photobucket.com/user/pescatore3/media/86fb835b-38ea-4685-947f-cfa2adeef9ea_zps7117f3ce.jpg.html)
The torpedo knob is also hardwood.
Daron, that guys had that on there for seven days also... I've been watching that one as well. ;)
Sal, the handle that Penn had before the torpedoes is called the "coffee grinder" handle. It existed on many reels like the model f, model k, and the Seahawks to name a few... And according to some really hardcore Penn collectors on ORCA that was the standard before the torpedoes. Also, I don't believe that reel was ever opened because the screws had no sign of damage, which back in the day was not a concern for a fisherman. They weren't as careful as we are because it was used to provide food or money not aesthetics to the mantle. Not only that but the box is worth more than $200 (my guess is closer to $500). We've all seen the lighthouse box alone go for over $100 on ebay. Not a big deal, just surprised by your price tag. Promise me if you get one you'll sell it to me for $200 ;)
Thanks
Dom
Dom, I know about the coffee grind knob, but never seen it on the larger senators, except the one with the oil port as shown on the second reel. the screw heads didn't look that clean to me , but could be wrong. :-\
Sal,
My guess is that Penn probably used what they had until it ran out... like everything else they have done in the past from boxes, to handles and side plates.
As for the screw heads ... they look good to me. The handle looks to be the right size to go on that reel, but I could be wrong. I don't think the guy put a sea hawk handle on a 9/0 back in 1938 but could be wrong there too. Looks all original to me. I hope I have the opportunity to bid again next time so I can tell you from first hand knowledge instead of speculation. ;)
Thanks
Dom
You were had by shill bidding at a pawn shop. When you see bidders that do 50% of there business with that bidder then it is usually employees running up the bid. Have seen it many times and it is against ebay rules. That reel may get listed again. The winning bid I believe does 16% of his business with that seller. Some pawn shops are really crooked.
NN,
Thanks for that explanation. I've seen some shady stuff on there but never realized they play 3 card monte (old NY style with fake customers)... I'll stick to paying the price i wanna pay instead of letting them bid me up.
Sal,
I just saw your posting about it being the missing link to a collectors' collection... that would make more sense than the museum because I just realized whenever you hear museum in a title that means donations. ;)
Thanks
Dom
Quote from: broadway on June 28, 2014, 11:18:56 PM
Sal,
My guess is that Penn probably used what they had until it ran out... like everything else they have done in the past from boxes, to handles and side plates.
As for the screw heads ... they look good to me. The handle looks to be the right size to go on that reel, but I could be wrong. I don't think the guy put a sea hawk handle on a 9/0 back in 1938 but could be wrong there too. Looks all original to me. I hope I have the opportunity to bid again next time so I can tell you from first hand knowledge instead of speculation. ;)
Thanks
Dom
Dom, take a closer look at the screw heads, using the zoom feature, you will clearly see that the slots are not perfect. That reel has been opened.
As for the knob, not a big deal to replace a knob on a handle if you know what to do.
About what Dwight mentioned, yes it does happen and I know of some that did it.
You could usually spot them on a 16/0 that starts at a few dollars. If that reel doesn't go past $400 and it's your bid, you can rest assured that someone will outbid you at the last minute. Its a lousy game but unfortunately some still play it. Ebay is not perfect on many things :-\
Quote from: Alto Mare on June 29, 2014, 01:29:35 AM
, you can rest assured that someone will outbid you at the last minute. Its a lousy game but unfortunately some still play it. Ebay is not perfect on many things :-\
That is kinda one thing that they could improve on by using a so-called rolling end of auction. That is, the auction keeps going until there are no more bids for two minutes or so. One of the other auction sites does that; it works very well. Keeps bidding fairer at the end.
.
Sal, Tweaked screws or not... we can all change screws so that's not a great test, but the rest of the reel is consistent with what I've seen of a Penn 4/0 (on ORCA) including the "coffee grinder" knob. I wish the people bidding agreed with you and quit bidding at $200. :-\
Here's a link to a drawing of a 1936 Senator...http://stripers247.com/historyofpennreels.htm
Dom
Yes, you are right buddy, but this wasn't about the screws. Not that it mattered to me, but usually the screws tell the story if a reel was opened or not.
If I see one of the same listed, I will make sure give it a shot, so me and you could negotiate big red ;).
On another note, I believe I owe you some $, please let me know how much.
LOL... you know you got first dibs on her ;)
PM'd
Dom
To see if something is being shill bid all you have to do is click on the number bids showing. A list of all bidders will come up. Then click on individual bidders and you can then see the percentage of business this bidder does with this seller.
I have seen them doing 100% with that seller. How do you know it is a pawn shop doing this. Look at the sellers number of transactions. If it is a couple thousand then it is a big business like a pawn shop. After looking at the bidder percentages you can put two and two together.
Dwight, thanks for pointing that out and it makes perfect sense to me.
If you look back at the bidding history, looks like (99) gave it a push towards the end.
50% of activities with that seller is a lot.
Dwight, I was wondering how you found that information. I've been pretty active on ebay for several years, but didn't know how to find out when there was a shill bidder.
I'm not sure that the pawn shops even know about this, otherwise they would be opening new accounts more frequently.
I have some questions.
When you click on bid history, it's only good for thirty days. If I bid on one item in that thirty day period, then all of my bids are with that seller. It makes it look like I'm a shill too.
If Dom bid $1000, then maybe he's "a***y (99)", with 50% bid activity with this seller. If this is the case, then would you have to look to see how much bidding the buyer has done recently?
If he's bid on multiple items in the last month, and still has a high percentage with this seller, then it's pretty obviously a shill. Someone like me, who usually doesn't buy more than one to two items a month isn't going to give enough information.
This is a new aspect of ebay for me; am I making sense?