Reel Repair by Alan Tani

General Maintenance Tips => Fishing Antiques and Collectables => Topic started by: Penn Chronology on October 30, 2015, 06:23:48 AM

Title: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Penn Chronology on October 30, 2015, 06:23:48 AM
This is an experiment. My first piece of published work was in 2011. Ray Hodges aka "Superhook" bought a rough EVH Commander Ross--14/O big game reel. These are rare in any condition. Ray decided to restore the reel and I wanted to write about the restoration as Ray was going through it. The folks at ORCA were kind enough to publish the article in their bi-monthly magazine.

Since there are so many tutorials here, I figured there might be room for one more, so here goes::

(http://i380.photobucket.com/albums/oo244/m3040c/EVH%20Reel%20News%20Article/Reel%20News%20Article--EVH%20Commander%20Ross%20Resto--pg.1%201179%20x%201572%20590%20x%20786_zpsecotsdvw.jpg)

(http://i380.photobucket.com/albums/oo244/m3040c/EVH%20Reel%20News%20Article/Reel%20News%20Article--EVH%20Commander%20Ross%20Resto--pg.2%201263%20x%201635%20632%20x%20818_zpsilbhukuq.jpg)

(http://i380.photobucket.com/albums/oo244/m3040c/EVH%20Reel%20News%20Article/Reel%20News%20Article--EVH%20Commander%20Ross%20Resto--pg.3%201196%20x%201602%20598%20x%20801_zpsk0rg6iek.jpg)

(http://i380.photobucket.com/albums/oo244/m3040c/EVH%20Reel%20News%20Article/Reel%20News%20Article--EVH%20Commander%20Ross%20Resto--pg.4%201166%20x%201590%20583%20x%20795_zpsqdjy3pkm.jpg)

(http://i380.photobucket.com/albums/oo244/m3040c/EVH%20Reel%20News%20Article/Reel%20News%20Article--EVH%20Commander%20Ross%20Resto--pg.5%201166%20x%201581%20583%20x%20790_zps3nfnsl7b.jpg)

That's it, hope you guys enjoy the article.
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Tightlines667 on October 30, 2015, 06:39:54 AM
Great stuff!

Somehow I knew you would have 'just what the doctor ordered'.

Thanks for sharing this here.  I enjoyed the read.  Now...
if I only knew where I could find an Edward Vom Hofe Commander Ross 14/0?
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Penn Chronology on October 31, 2015, 12:17:48 AM
John,

Glad you enjoyed the article. Here is a picture of the reel after Ray got done with it. The published picture did not do it justice.

(http://i380.photobucket.com/albums/oo244/m3040c/Edward%20Vom%20Hofe/100_0347_zpsdrx1kpk5.jpg)

Good luck on your quest for a Commander Ross. They do pop up from time to time, if you have to ask how much they sell for, then you cannot afford one. They are big bucks. That is why I do not own one. The one that Ray restored was a very beat reel when Ray received it. He put many hours into that restoration.
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Superhook on October 31, 2015, 03:02:12 AM

Here is a before photo .

It was a real let down to see the crappy looking weld job on the head plate side of the spool flange........probably how i managed to win the Auction. ( Weld was not shown or mentioned in the auction description...oh well .)

(http://i1130.photobucket.com/albums/m531/kingfisher57/_DSC0130_1.jpg) (http://s1130.photobucket.com/user/kingfisher57/media/_DSC0130_1.jpg.html)

After a trip to the Machine Shop the Lathe Operator did a perfect clean up by just cleaning the weld off and none of the original metal . No heat distortion from the weld . BONUS.

(http://i1130.photobucket.com/albums/m531/kingfisher57/100_0301_2.jpg) (http://s1130.photobucket.com/user/kingfisher57/media/100_0301_2.jpg.html)

All polished up and no ugly bird crap weld . Looks a lot better now .

(http://i1130.photobucket.com/albums/m531/kingfisher57/100_0309_1.jpg) (http://s1130.photobucket.com/user/kingfisher57/media/100_0309_1.jpg.html)
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Penn Chronology on October 31, 2015, 05:28:11 AM
A thing of beauty. You made your reel into a World Class Commander Ross :o :o :o
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Superhook on October 31, 2015, 08:10:08 AM


Thanks Mike.    They are a beautiful reel and strongly built too.

To give others an idea of the value of a 14/0 , in May 2011 this one sold for  US$1600 at auction which grew to US$1960.00  including premium & the $100.00 to ship to OZ .

The spool fix was $100 and whatever the wet & dry and polish cost. The result , i think was good and to see Edward Vom Hofe's reel is a piece of mechanical Artwork to enjoy . I think i am lucky.

It was at the cheapest end of the auction prices for a complete 14/0 sold over quite a few years.  EVH 16/0's go about double that so i don't think i will be buying one of them. They are are substantially larger than a 14/0 .  If you keep looking you will find them cheaper and dearer over time. A 14/0 cradle reel with butt , no tip , sold for $US$2,200.00 + premium just recently .

The Commander Ross EVH's were made in 10/0 , 12/0  14/0 and 16/0 sizes with and without cradles  . The cradle options were available for an extra $30.00 on the 12/0 , 14/0 & 16/0 sizes  in the early 1940's.

You don't need a 14/0 to enjoy quality . The 621 series from 1/0 up are basically of the same design , beauty and strength  .


Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Dominick on October 31, 2015, 02:31:16 PM
Good article.  Thanks for keeping some of that history alive.  Dominick
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Penn Chronology on October 31, 2015, 02:31:32 PM
QuoteYou don't need a 14/0 to enjoy quality . The 621 series from 1/0 up are basically of the same design , beauty and strength  .

I agree, all EVH reels are superb works of mechanical design; but, even though I own a few of them up to 9/0, there is a little man in my head that says I do need a 14 or 16/0. I just cannot get that little brain brat to shut up............. >:(
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Penn Chronology on October 31, 2015, 02:34:08 PM
QuoteGood article.  Thanks for keeping some of that history alive.  Dominick

Thanks Dom. It is all about the history. ;D
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Oceanreels on October 31, 2015, 02:46:05 PM
Ray, VERY nice work.
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: johndtuttle on October 31, 2015, 03:29:07 PM
Beautiful job restoring, an inspiration to us all.  ;)
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: The Great Maudu on December 03, 2015, 03:38:47 PM
That is an amazing polishing job Ray. The contrast between the brass and silver is the highlight for me.
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: sdlehr on December 03, 2015, 04:52:40 PM
Absolutely beautiful! I never would have thought that spool could have been returned to such a beautiful condition without replating. It is inspirational!
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Penn Chronology on December 04, 2015, 03:10:04 AM
QuoteThat is an amazing polishing job Ray. The contrast between the brass and silver is the highlight for me.

QuoteAbsolutely beautiful! I never would have thought that spool could have been returned to such a beautiful condition without replating. It is inspirational!

It is the properties of Nickel Silver that makes it all worth while. Nothing polishes like German Silver. It polishes fairly easy and the results can be so rich and stunning. The only negative is the alloy is not always good. German Silver can be sort of a Pot Metal and the alloying elements that give it its high quality are sometimes skimped on by some makers. There is basically no set rules for Nickel Silver, so it can vary in quality. The vom Hofe reels are made from high quality German Silver, but, not all reels share that high quality. You know as soon as you start polishing, if it looks more like brass color than silver, you know the quality is low.
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: The Great Maudu on December 04, 2015, 05:40:23 AM
Is there a way to tell whether or not a reel is made with German silver?
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Steve-O on December 04, 2015, 05:44:34 AM
Not magnetic and will blacken a polishing cloth.
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Penn Chronology on December 05, 2015, 12:09:50 AM
QuoteInsert Quote

Is there a way to tell whether or not a reel is made with German silver?

If it is not plated, the color of German Silver is unmistakable.

(http://i380.photobucket.com/albums/oo244/m3040c/DSC00092512x340.jpg)

(http://i380.photobucket.com/albums/oo244/m3040c/DSC01158816x612.jpg)

(http://i380.photobucket.com/albums/oo244/m3040c/Templar-300-7.jpg)

All of these reels are high quality non-plated German Silver. German Silver accepts chrome plating very well, so many early reels were plated. The Commander Ross 14/O in this thread was originally Chrome plated.
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: broadway on January 11, 2016, 05:32:26 AM
Beautiful job on that restoration, Ray.  You had a rough diamond and turned it into a diamond in the rough.  First class job on a first class reel manufacturer.
Thanks for sharing the history, Mike and Ray for the tune up on this cool piece of Deep Sea History.
Dom
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Penn Chronology on January 11, 2016, 03:33:49 PM
QuoteThanks for sharing the history, Mike and Ray for the tune up on this cool piece of Deep Sea History.

Ray has a World Class collection! Someday there will be a museum in Brisbane highlighting his tackle!
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: broadway on January 11, 2016, 06:27:13 PM
That may be the only thing that would get me on a plane for that long. ;)
I've seen some of Ray's treasures but I'm pretty certain we haven't scratched the surface.
Dom
Title: Re: Article--Restoration of a Edward vom Hofe--Commander Ross--14/O
Post by: Maxed Out on January 11, 2016, 09:43:15 PM
Quote from: broadway on January 11, 2016, 06:27:13 PM
That may be the only thing that would get me on a plane for that long. ;)
I've seen some of Ray's treasures but I'm pretty certain we haven't scratched the surface.
Dom



 .....said the kettle to the pot  ;) :D