Reel Repair by Alan Tani

Fishing Rods => Fishing Rods => Topic started by: Wolfram M on May 19, 2022, 03:28:17 AM

Title: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: Wolfram M on May 19, 2022, 03:28:17 AM
Hopefully I finish this one, I have an older one that I never did finish. (thought I did, but nah. there are two guides missing.)

Started on Monday with a nice Batson ultralight blank, a set of Alps guides that Ron at the Rod shop picked out for me, and a nice short cork handle with hidden lock nut. I got the handle on, which required no reaming as it was right on size out of the box.

(https://i.imgur.com/EvBrdOch.jpg)

(https://i.imgur.com/EgoEwSkh.jpg)

(https://i.imgur.com/TCpTbbRh.jpg)

(https://i.imgur.com/pglT5Ggh.jpg)

I wrapped the rod with masking tape, and packed the cavity between the tape rolls and then the gap between the cork handle and the rearmost tape roll with rod bond paste. I made sure it's as sealed up as much as possible, as the foregrip is also the reel seat lock nut.

I did get some squeeze-out onto the grips and the reel seat but I cleaned it up the best I could. I'll polish up the reel seat scratches later.

I built a new wrapping jig today, and will start tomorrow by wrapping the hook keeper in place. If I like the way it fits, I'll tackle the first guide, and we'll go from there.

Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: steelfish on May 19, 2022, 05:36:01 AM
Keeping an eye (one) on this !!
Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: JasonGotaProblem on May 19, 2022, 11:12:09 AM
Sandpaper is your friend. And acetone does a great job of removing epoxy overruns as long as it hasn't already dried.

Prepare yourself. The entrance to this rabbit hole is slippery. Soon every rod you own is fair game for improvement. But at least its fun.
Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: philaroman on May 19, 2022, 08:37:50 PM
interesting blank -- how does the tip look?  (can't find RX7 UL spin -- guessing DISCONTINUED)
do you think the specs are a misprint -- 1/52 instead of 1/32 oz. MIN lure?
otherwise, if it can throw 1/52 (<1/2g), wouldn't it handle line well under 2#?
Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: Wolfram M on May 19, 2022, 08:44:37 PM
Nope. Rabbit hole avoided-I was finishing the LAST eyelet, I had all the wrapping finished and was pulling the tag end under, and the electrician who was working in my classroom dropped his toolbag on the counter I was working on. I was doing good, too.

(https://i.imgur.com/gEeEXnzh.jpg)

(https://i.imgur.com/PMfVEW2h.jpg)

The handle end of the rod bounced off the 3rd stand, into the floor, and snapped the last 12" of the rod tip off. Right at the second-to-last eyelet.

(https://i.imgur.com/2kaTQrjh.jpg)

Since the last 12" of rod tip is missing, the rod is so stiff now that I doubt it'd ever cast worth a damn. I've spooled it up and mounted the reel, and I'll go out this afternoon and see how bad it really is.
Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: Wolfram M on May 19, 2022, 11:30:18 PM
It's pretty bad. The line flows nicely through the four guides left on the rod but it has very little flex. I'd call it a "heavy" action but it's not strong enough for heavy fish. If it had the same action but was 7ft long and around 0.600" at the butt it'd make a good heavy bass fishing rod...

It does catch fish, though. Took it out and with a 1/8" split shot and a short shank hook, it'll sling a red worm and a light float about 35 feet, max.
Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: Wolfram M on May 19, 2022, 11:32:39 PM
Quote from: philaroman on May 19, 2022, 08:37:50 PMinteresting blank -- how does the tip look?  (can't find RX7 UL spin -- guessing DISCONTINUED)
do you think the specs are a misprint -- 1/52 instead of 1/32 oz. MIN lure?
otherwise, if it can throw 1/52 (<1/2g), wouldn't it handle line well under 2#?


Yeah I think it's a misprint, the tip was 1.75mm but now it's a hollow 3.5mm OD. Even after catching a few small fish on it I'm super disappointed that it is broken off.
Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: steelfish on May 20, 2022, 12:23:04 AM
dang, that was a really short life of the rod   >:(
 
time to find another blank

Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: philaroman on May 20, 2022, 12:51:30 AM
Quote from: Wolfram M on May 19, 2022, 11:32:39 PM
Quote from: philaroman on May 19, 2022, 08:37:50 PMinteresting blank -- how does the tip look?  (can't find RX7 UL spin -- guessing DISCONTINUED)
do you think the specs are a misprint -- 1/52 instead of 1/32 oz. MIN lure?
otherwise, if it can throw 1/52 (<1/2g), wouldn't it handle line well under 2#?


Yeah I think it's a misprint, the tip was 1.75mm but now it's a hollow 3.5mm OD. Even after catching a few small fish on it I'm super disappointed that it is broken off.

12" off the tip is CATASTROPHIC for a UL
might as well break off neatly cut off some more
& turn it into a butt section for a 2-pc UL
the 2nd UL blank could be well under 5', so S&H is much more reasonable
Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: happyhooker on May 20, 2022, 01:36:31 AM
Tough "break".  Probably could repair the blank, and since the break is right at a guide, you would hardly notice the repair.  Have done this to rods, including ULs, with some degree of success.

Frank
Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: Wolfram M on May 20, 2022, 01:37:37 AM
This 2-piece rod thing is a good idea. It's a pretty skinny rod but I'll look around and see what I can find.

It does catch fish, though.

(https://i.imgur.com/TmSqgnLh.jpg)

It only casts about 35 feet with 6lb test mono and a 1/4oz combined float+sinker+hook.

Frank if you think it can be repaired, how would you go about doing it? it's broken right at the start of the most flexible bit of the rod. I still have both pieces.

As it is now, It fits very neatly behind the seat of the truck...which was an original desire for this rod but the 6ft 6in blank didn't fit.
Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: oc1 on May 20, 2022, 06:54:22 AM
Bummer.

Find a 2.5 inch long piece of stainless rod or wire that will just fit inside the broken ends.  Epoxy it in place and then wrap over a 3 inch long section.  It will hold, but you will still hate it.  An short UL rod with a three inch dead spot right in the most important section won't load correctly.
Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: philaroman on May 20, 2022, 04:28:06 PM
the 2-pc option may not be as easy, as pre-Covid  :( :'(
don't know what happened to fleaBay ??? 
astronomical prices & no selection :o
once upon a time, you could get a no-name 4' UL blank 
for little more than $20, shipped...  less, for 3' UL Ice blank
Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: Wolfram M on May 20, 2022, 08:32:48 PM
Yeah, but Get Bit has carbon ice rod blanks for 8 bucks right now. This seems like the way.
Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: philaroman on May 20, 2022, 10:09:57 PM
read closer: no UL option & they're solid -- not, hollow
can't make a tip-over-butt ferrule 
Title: Re: Wrapping my first rod.
Post by: happyhooker on May 21, 2022, 01:59:06 AM
As far as rod repair, you can look on the web and find all sorts of potential solutions.  You want one that has the best chance of restoring the action of the rod to what it should have been if not broken.  That being said, your expectations should be modest.

The theory that makes the most sense to me is that stated by Roger O'Quinn in his many online posts.  Look for his "Repairing Broken Rods" article, which I believe was originally posted on Rodbuilding.org, and has been reposted and quoted many times since.  I believe Mr. O'Quinn is now deceased, but he remains a legendary guru in the rather specialized topic of rod repair.  The above article provides repair advice for various types of breaks that one may see.

I don't necessarily advocate following the O'Quinn article advice to the letter (although I think you could.)  But, look at his reasoning, modify it to your own liking and go from there.

I used his techniques a few years back on a no-name green 6 ft 10 in. one-piece rod I found in a trash can. A no-namer wouldn't normally receive a lot of attention (which is maybe why it was in a trash can), but this one had nice gold-colored guides that looked like quality, along with better-than-average wraps and a nice cork handle that led me to think it might be a decent stick. That repair has held up nicely and the rod had hauled in many a fish.  I think that one (I don't have the rod right in front of me) had a break between guides, rather than right at one, but the repair is not that noticeable, unless you are looking for it.  I also used the same technique on an old black Shimano FX-2652 two-piece, and that one had the break right at a guide, I think the first one down from the tip.  The guide was re-installed right on top of the break, and the repair is barely noticeable.  That rod just landed a 10 lb. bigmouth buffalo last week, and if you know buffalo, you know that rod got a workout.

Frank