penn fathom star 40

[pullrachet]

New sizes are out...they look good on paper, has anyone tried out the 40?  My first impression is how the reel weighs so little (18.7 oz) for an all aluminum reel.  Anyone have anything to add?

[akfish]

I got one for my girlfriend to use for Alaskan halibut this summer. I was quite impressed. She fished with with straight 80# spectra. Her biggest fish was a 70 pounder. It handled it no problem. Personally, I like it more than the comparable Shimano Tekota.

[pullrachet]

do yo see any possible weaknesses or design flaws? 

[akfish]

I don't see any problems after one season of use. It's got a great drag. It's all metal -- side plates as well  as frame -- and a nice handle. I always worry about level winds on reels meant to be fished hard, but we ad no problems this summer.