Unpopular Takes

Started by slosh, November 14, 2026, 01:56:38 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

JasonGotaProblem, Patudo, Hardy Boy and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Midway Tommy

I agree, Greg. Fixing a little line twist every now and then, especially if it's done frequently, is a lot easier and takes a lot less time than sitting there fishing-less trying to untangle a dang backlash.  ;) 
Love those open face spinning reels! (Especially ABU & ABU/Zebco Cardinals)

Tommy D (ORCA), NE



Favorite Activity? ............... In our boat fishing
RELAXING w/ MY BEST FRIEND (My wife Bonnie)

slosh

How about the Abu ProMax/BlackMax reels? They palm pretty well and they've got no quit in 'em. And you can scoop 'em up for cheap once in awhile if you're diligent.

Speaking of possibly unpopular opinions, braid will fix all of your line twist issues in spinning reels. Old reels handle original Fireline just fine, and you get more sensitivity and casting distance. And you won't blow up a spool if you wind it up wet and stow it away. Trade-off is wind knots, but worth it to me. I do still run mono on my live bait/float fishing setups (old ultralight reels on fiberglass rods), but everything else is braid now.

slosh

Quote from: Gfish on Today at 06:09:03 PMYeah, but it's a great thread idea. For me the main conventional/bait casting vs spinning/spin casting thing, is the difference between backlash and line twist problems.
Both are controllable, but not all the time. A nasty backlash is usually worse for me than line twist problems.
Then there's all the other differences. Line capacity, drag function, casting distance, an "eggbeater" sticking out from the rod and making things clumsy, a bait-caster needing detailed casting adjustments for each different weight used, etc., etc., ...

Yesterday I practiced with an Abu Revo Toro Beast casting a hookless 1oz. spoon on a windy day. Was surprised at how well it did. But, it took awhile to get 3-different adjustments set right. Also, I knew I could get 5-10 more feet using the right spinning reel, if the line wasn't too twisted (especially when those wind gusts hit it). So, the bait-caster won that one, with the magnetic, centrifugal and spool friction controls, but these are finicky and expensive in a good quality reel.

To me baitcaster vs spinning comes down to this:
Baitcasters are smaller relative to their drag/line capacity. A 20 lb-class spinning reel is enormous compared to a 20 lb-class baitcaster.
Baitcasters allow you to work the water a bit faster if you're a serious bass fisherman.
Baitcasters allow you to cast a bit farther if you're a serious distance caster (though that gets blurry fast in real-world conditions).

I don't know that there will ever be a baitcaster that will outdo a spinning reel on baits under 1/4 oz. I've tried to tune a couple small baitcasters for that over the years, and it makes for a cool party trick but that's about it. If I need to throw a crappie jig a long way, give me my Daiwa SS 700 or 1300, some 8lb braid, and a 7ft light action rod.