Okuma Stratus SGT-30 handle paddle missing a chunk

[wahoowad]

I can't find a replacement handle for this Okuma SGT-30 (made for Dick's). During a deep clean/lube I busted a chunk of the handle paddle off while adding some oil. Is there a material I can try to fill it in? I thought of building it up with epoxy like E6000 but that would adhere to the cap and I'd never get it off again.