Unpopular Takes

Started by slosh, November 14, 2026, 01:56:38 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Patudo, slosh, Hardy Boy, jim mcnamara (+ 1 Hidden) and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

slosh

Quote from: oc1 on November 14, 2026, 07:06:10 PMI notice that all the "unpopular takes" here relate to spinning reels rather than conventional reels.  Good job guys.  That is as it should be.

I got you! The palming sideplate Ambassadeurs are not nearly as good as the dual-knob models.

oc1

Neither of those Ambassadeurs palm well.  They waste too much space under the hood.  Shimano showed the world how to make a palming reel.

Decker

Quote from: oc1 on November 14, 2026, 07:06:10 PMI notice that all the "unpopular takes" here relate to spinning reels rather than conventional reels.  Good job guys.  That is as it should be.

Eggbeaters, all!  ;D
And you know that you're over the hill,
When your mind makes a promise that your body can't fill,
Doin' the old folks boogie and boogie we will,
'Cause to us the thought is as good as a thrill...

Midway Tommy

Quote from: Decker on November 14, 2026, 08:44:43 PM
Quote from: oc1 on November 14, 2026, 07:06:10 PMI notice that all the "unpopular takes" here relate to spinning reels rather than conventional reels.  Good job guys.  That is as it should be.

Eggbeaters, all!  ;D

HA!   :D   They must be a little too complicated for some people to know how to use correctly.  ;)  >:D  ;D
Love those open face spinning reels! (Especially ABU & ABU/Zebco Cardinals)

Tommy D (ORCA), NE



Favorite Activity? ............... In our boat fishing
RELAXING w/ MY BEST FRIEND (My wife Bonnie)

Decker

Quote from: Midway Tommy on November 14, 2026, 09:52:45 PMThey must be a little too complicated for some people to know how to use correctly.  ;)  >:D  ;D

Guilty as charged; I have been seen casting a spinner guides up. How else could I reel right-handed? Luckily I'm left-handed and adapted eventually.

Speaking of Shimano conventionals, what's up with the "Fightin' Star" thingy on the Speedmaster TSM reels?? :o

And you know that you're over the hill,
When your mind makes a promise that your body can't fill,
Doin' the old folks boogie and boogie we will,
'Cause to us the thought is as good as a thrill...

oldmanjoe

#20
QuoteSpeaking of Shimano conventionals, what's up with the "Fightin' Star" thingy on the Speedmaster TSM reels?? :o

Basic idea is that it is a preset star drag , that you can change the preset . Like a lever drag .
Grandpa`s words of wisdom......Joey that thing between your shoulders is not a hat rack.....    use it.....
A mind is like a parachute, it only work`s  when it is open.......
Character is doing the right thing when nobody is looking .   There are too many people who think that the only thing that!s right is to get by,and the only thing that's wrong is to get caught .
The power of Observation   , It`s all about the Details ..
" Life " It`s a thinking man`s game
 "Mitten im blickfeld versteckt 
" I cannot teach anybody anything   I can only make them think "     - Socrates-
 Forget about all the reasons why something may not work. You only need to find one good reason why it will.   Alto Mare

Patudo

Quote from: slosh on November 14, 2026, 07:54:39 PMThe palming sideplate Ambassadeurs are not nearly as good as the dual-knob models.

Interesting... How so?

slosh

For whatever reason the palming sideplate models do not hold up as well for me. Gears get grindy after hard use, whereas the dual knob models seem to just run forever. I've had a few of both and, except for a couple loaner reels, all of my Abus are dual-knob.

thorhammer

Hate torpedo knobs on any reel. I do have one Cardinal 5, I believe a 5, on shelf. I had acquired some Cardinals and parts and sent the whole lot to our Harry K a few years ago, because he is a prince.

I can palm a basketball, so palming a round Ambassaduer is where I like to be and I have several dozen. The little low profile reels of any type are just that, little, and my thumb barely fits. I can wrap a VMAG entirely out if sight in my hand and while it is a decent reel, I don't like fishing it. Agree with SLOSH, like the dual knobs better. Why? Dunno, maybe it's the retro look or maybe a little better cast control. We fish the same water in OBX so likely we both compare everything to Blue Yonder and Mag Elite as the benchmark, or Rocket / Sports Mag for a levelwind.


oc1

#24
One of the first palming reel, the Shimano Bantam 100, may have been the best palming reels.

CincyDavid

I am another non-fan of most Mitchells...finicky to work on and tune, and even with all of the complex gearing, the bail spins the wrong way. To me, it was a case of "why do it the easy way when it's just as easy to do it the hard way?"

thorhammer

Quote from: oc1 on November 16, 2026, 07:47:39 PMOne of the first palming reel, the Shimano Bantam 100, may have been the best palming reels.

My first was a 5500C. Second was a Bantam 100, with the teak handles. Still have both. Love the little Bantam, but it was better in my 12 year old hands. I still sling it now and again.

Third was an Ambassadeur 100, narrow and with a combo profile not unlike the Mags. I would def consider this a palming reel from the 70's. Still have it too. Tried swapping the bushes for bearings but they are different from other Ambassadeurs and aren't the same size left and right; didn't work very well.

oc1

#27
John, it seems our difference of opinion is mostly about anatomy.  I ain't changing mine :>)  All of the low-profile reels feel better my hand than any Ambassadeur.  The diameter of the ABU tail plate is much larger than the diameter of the spool which is why I think they could be more compact. 

Because of its size, I was in love with the little VMAG for a while,  I think it was you who turned me onto them.  But couldn't keep them running in saltwater.

I never before heard of an Ambassadeur 100; unless it was the 100th Anniversary set?  Was it the same frame diameter as the rest?

thorhammer

Steve, 1000, not 100- I had a typo. You are certainly on target about plate vs spool diameter. I DO enjoy my Lew's BB1-NG which is a souped up VMag, basically. The original Lew's were made by Shimano and Ryobi, and I think Ryobi was first but forget the order. Yeah, I wouldn't want those in salt, and I only really use a couple of my Abus in salt which get a full teardown when I get home.

Sorry. OP! Off in the woods. It happens around here...

Gfish

#29
Yeah, but it's a great thread idea. For me the main conventional/bait casting vs spinning/spin casting thing, is the difference between backlash and line twist problems.
Both are controllable, but not all the time. A nasty backlash is usually worse for me than line twist problems.
Then there's all the other differences. Line capacity, drag function, casting distance, an "eggbeater" sticking out from the rod and making things clumsy, a bait-caster needing detailed casting adjustments for each different weight used, etc., etc., ...

Yesterday I practiced with an Abu Revo Toro Beast casting a hookless 1oz. spoon on a windy day. Was surprised at how well it did. But, it took awhile to get 3-different adjustments set right. Also, I knew I could get 5-10 more feet using the right spinning reel, if the line wasn't too twisted (especially when those wind gusts hit it). So, the bait-caster won that one, with the magnetic, centrifugal and spool friction controls, but these are finicky and expensive in a good quality reel.
Fishing tackle is an art form and all fish caught on the right tackle are"Gfish"!